Blog Entry

Big Ten poll reactions, Week 6

Posted on: October 10, 2011 2:51 pm
Edited on: October 10, 2011 2:54 pm
  •  
 
Posted by Adam Jacobi

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the Big Ten fared, from the top of the polls to the bottom, and what it means.

(AP/Coaches) 

4/4. Wisconsin

This is right where I've got the Badgers, both in terms of resume and power. I'm more of a power guy when it comes to these rankings -- I think squabbling over the minutiae of Team X's non-conference opponents and Team Y's non-conference opponents and how those other teams have fared over the course of the season is of secondary importance to whether Team X can beat Team Y straight up -- but in terms of resume strength, Wisconsin's win over Nebraska is looking better and better than Oklahoma dispatching Florida State. Also I'm head over heels for Russell Wilson. But! I still think Oklahoma would beat Wisconsin, which is what matters, so let's keep the Badgers at 4 here and nobody has a valid gripe.

11/10. Michigan

The Wolverines passed their first road test with a 42-24 comeback win over Northwestern. Denard Robinson threw for over 300 yards and ran 25 times for over 100 more, but he also had to miss some time after taking a big hit. Robinson also threw three picks in the first half (though, to be fair, none in the second). Both of those could be troubling indicators for the rest of the season, considering the problems Robinson has had with both turnovers and injuries over his career. At any rate, I still don't have Michigan this high, but if UM goes to Michigan State and picks up a win there, it'll have earned a Top 10 spot. This should be a great game to watch this week.

14/14. Nebraska

On one hand: that was an impressive comeback win for the Cornhuskers over Ohio State. On the other hand: still no victories over ranked opponents, and the comeback probably doesn't happen if Joe Bauserman doesn't go all JOE BAUSERMANNNNN on the unsuspecting Nebraska fans eight rows up on every pass play. So I'm still not sold on Nebraska, but once you get past the Top 10 or so, college football is such a mess that it's all right if Nebraska's ranked here. I suppose.

16/15. Illinois

But if we're really being honest, it's probably Illinois and not Nebraska who deserves that spot at No. 14, because not only are the Illini undefeated, they've got the best win of the two teams with a comeback victory against Arizona State (currently ranked 18th or 20th, depending on which poll you trust, and if you trust the coaches poll I hate you). We'll have our first good point of comparison to make between the Illini and Huskers this week, as Ohio State comes to Champaign. If Illinois handles OSU with any measure of ease, it'll be time to start giving them a real push up the polls, and that ought to include jumping Nebraska.

23/19. Michigan State

I haven't found any stats on it, but Michigan State must have crushed Brigham Young East last week (I assume that's what the "BYE" on the Spartans' schedule stands for), because MSU made a nice little jump in both polls this week. I'm not high on MSU and haven't been since Notre Dame swallowed up that vaunted rushing attack back in Week 3. Redemption could come on Saturday when Michigan visits Spartan Stadium, and if Michigan State picks up the win, it'll probably deserve a spot in the rankings, right around here.

NR/25. Penn State

In this week's edition of The Coaches Poll Needs To Be Dumped In That Woodchipper From Fargo, we have Penn State being ranked 25th in the coaches poll. 24th in that poll? Baylor. Baylor! Baylor would destroy Penn State. Nobody who's participating in the coaches poll actually watches Penn State, clearly, they just see a Big Ten team at 5-1 and figure it's time to rank that team. No no no no. PSU had a nice win last Saturday beating Iowa 13-3, but that wasn't a Top 25 performance by any stretch, and nothing from the rest of Penn State's season (including squeakers against Temple and Indiana) indicates otherwise. In the AP poll, where the voters actually watch the games, Penn State is 30th. That's not even close! Why can't the world just ignore the coaches poll and why does the BCS have to factor it into its rankings argggghhhhhh

Also receiving votes:

Penn State (22 AP votes)
  •  
Comments
kkjyywlpo
Since: Dec 2, 2011
Posted on: December 16, 2011 11:40 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator




Since: Aug 18, 2010
Posted on: October 10, 2011 4:34 pm
 

Big Ten poll reactions, Week 6

I think Wisconsin is in a wierd spot.  They are solid at #4, but have no control over their own destiny when it comes to the NC.  Even if they win out, they need help to get to one of the top spots.  I see them passing no one or getting passed by any team unless a loss is involved.  I hope they win out, along with the SEC champ, Big 12 champ, and even the ACC champ.  That may move us along to at least a "plus one" scenerio. 



Since: Mar 15, 2007
Posted on: October 10, 2011 4:16 pm
 

Big Ten poll reactions, Week 6

While I agree with you that Oklahoma (or really any of the top three) would likely beat Wisconsin on a neutral field, it would be a terrific game that I'd love to see. That's not to say that I think Wisconsin would definitely lose against any of the top three, just that likely wouldn't win. That being said, I think any team in the country would have their hands full with Wisconsin's offense.


The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com